Thursday, January 12, 2012

Curiouser and Curiouser: Martha and Enoch


 

Response and refutation to the Addie Hoyt Fargo blog information for 1/4/2012

An unidentified older gentleman from Lake Mills that was involved in law enforcement reached out to Rosemary out of the blue to encourage her to pursue a quest to develop a conspiracy theory about the death of her great, great aunt.  Go figure.

Considering all the information Rosemary has twisted, ignored and made up from scratch I have to question the veracity and true content of this conversation.  Rosemary made up the content of a conversation with Dr. Peterson where she claims he told her Addie didn’t die of diphtheria.  That was simply untrue.  I spoke with Dr. Peterson (as did the reporter from the Lake Mills Leader) and he stuck by the forensic report and discounted, entirely, Rosemary’s ‘statement without fact’.  He stated that Rosemary would not be content with any other finding than death by gun shot. ….or at least foul play of some sort.  This is one example. Over the coming weeks I will continue to expose  other examples. 

The vilification of E J Fargo cascades to living relatives whether Rosemary and her night watchman (or whatever his role really was in law enforcement) care to think.  I’m pretty sure I could substantiate a case of defamation of character without too awfully much trouble.

The bothersome part of Rosemary’s blog entry is the assertion by the night watchman that a murder actually occurred and that E J committed that murder.  Any responsible law enforcement officer would look at the “evidence” Rosemary constructed in conjunction with the real, hard evidence and come to the conclusion there's not even a semblance of a case against E J.  But so it goes….

And at the end Rosemary adds in, once again, that Addie didn’t die of diphtheria.  She doesn’t know whether this is true.  Mattie’s (wife #3) living relatives have stated publicly they believe she died of black diphtheria and the historical record supports that statement.

Rosemary continues to take the statement in Mary Wilson’s book out of context to exploit it for her less than honorable purposes.  If E J killed Addie then produce some evidence that makes sense.  The forensic examination didn’t confirm that supposition.

When I read the material Rosemary has constructed in relation to Addie Hoyt Fargo I really have to wonder about the accuracy and veracity of the work she’s done on Sears kit homes.

4 comments:

  1. I too have begun to read some of Rosemary's sears articles and in one she writes that contained in a bill of materials was 10# of putty. I have built 25 homes and 10 three story apartment buildings with garages without using even 10 oz.'s of putty. Besides, what kind of "architecural historian" writes about pre-cut homes? If she lives long enough she will be writing about Menards and Home Depot houses. Same thing, different era.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What was his birthday?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think it was in March.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Enoch was born March 14, 1850 according to the grave stone and historical information.

    ReplyDelete

Leave comments, please